Recently in Medical Malpractice Category

My cousin Judith Storey works for the Patient Advocacy Foundation, a non-profit in Hampton, Virginia.  I find what she does fascinating and thought it might be a useful resource for our clients and friends in Virginia.  The group administers the Virginia Cares Uninsured Program and they assist patients struggling to pay their medical bills who have chronic and severe illnesses.  The goal of the group is to ensure access to care.   In the past 12 months the group has helped well over a thousand new patients relieving them of about $3.4 million in health care costs and prescription medication costs through write offs, reductions and grants.   The group will make phone calls and persistently advocate on behalf of its clients to try to be sure that the patients are not overcharged, and when appropriate, they seek charity write offs on behalf of their patients.   It typically takes about 45 days and over a dozen phone calls to accomplish this in each particular case.  Many of those who the group helps have health insurance, but due to serious illness are overwhelmed by co-pays and deductibles.  Many of those assisted have been affected by layoffs and closures like what occurred at the International Paper Mill outside Franklin, VA.

 

If you or someone you know who lives in Virginia can use the assistance of this group and/or for more information, visit their website at http://www.pafcares.org/  My cousin Judith Storey has recently been named the Headquarters Assistant Director and I am very proud of the work that she does.

 

Goldberg, Finnegan & Mester is a law firm that represents those injured and disabled.   If you have suffered an injury due to medical malpractice, a car accident, or workman's compensation, call us at 888-213-8140 or visit our website at www.gfmjustice.com.   We also represent individulas in their claim for disability benefits such as long term disability denials, short term disability, and social security disability claims.

My one-year term as President of the Maryland Association for Justice ended last night at our Annual Presidents Dinner in Baltimore, MD.  The event was held at the Hilton which overlooks Camden Yards.   Robert Zarbin is now the President of MAJ. Mr. Zarbin is going to be an incredible leader, and he he has done a fantastic job as Legislative Chairman this year.  

I am proud of our accomplishments this year.   Our legislative team had an amazing year and we passed 3 new laws that will help our clients who are injured in Maryland car accidents.   One of the new laws increases the minimum limits of liability insurance from $20,000.00/$40,000.00 to $30,000.00/$60,000.00.  This is the first time these minimal limits have been increased since 1972.  I am also very proud of the strides Maryland Association for Justice made in the area of Membership.  We gained over 210 new members in the last year.   MAJ has an incredible staff (our Executive Director David Walls is top notch), an energized Board of Governors, and an engaged membership.  

  Last night was a great event.  There were many notables there including Governor O'Malley, Maryland Senate President Mike Miller, the Chief Judge of the Maryland Court of Special Appeals, Judge Harrell from the Court of Appeals and many other Judges, State Delegates, U.S. Rep. Frank Kratovil from the Eastern Shore, MD  and several State Senators including Senator Garragiola from Montgomery County and Delegate Joe Vallario (Chair of House Judiciary Committee).   One of the highlights for me was hearing U.S. Congressman Bruce Braley speak about the civil justice system.  Bruce Braley is a trial lawyer from Iowa who was elected to U.S. Congress a couple of years ago.   He is at the forefront of holding big corporations like BP (British Petroleum), Toyota, and the U.S. Chamber of Commerce accountable and honest in their presentations to Congress.  Last night several videos were played of Congressman Braley cross examining witnesses in committee hearings in order to get the truth out to the American People.  We are lucky to have a trial lawyer like him there.   

Baltimore trial lawyer Henry Dugan, George Tolley and Bruce Babij won the trial lawyer of the year award.  Henry Dugan gave a very moving a philosphical speech about the importance of the civil justice system, and in particular, the subpoena.   He won the award for the Mcquitty case in which his firm obtained a $13 Million dollar verdict in a case that had been rejected by 4 other law firms before coming to his firm.   The casewent to the Maryland Court of Appeals, and it made new law in Maryland regarding informed consent and essentially held that a patient must receive information about the risks and treatment options before undergoing medical treatment.  As a result of this case, medical doctors in Maryland are now being trained to give more information to patients about treatment options than they were previously.     

As I leave office, I feel very lucky to have had the privilege of serving as the MAJ President.   Our Association does amazing things for the community and for our injured clients.  As I am now getting involved in representing businesses and individuals harmed by the BP Oil Spill, and seeing what they are going through as a result of the gross negligence of BP, Transocean and Haliburton, I feel stronger than ever that open access to the civil justice system is absoultely necessary in a demoractic and capitalistic society.    

justice-scales-bw.jpg
The medical malpractice team at Goldberg, Finnegan & Mester is pleased to report that on February 4, 2010 the Illinois Supreme Court invalidated the Illinois cap on non economic damages finding that it violated the separation of powers doctrine in the Illinois Constitution.  The opinion was issued by Chief Judge Fitzgerald. The case involved the alleged improper medical care provided during the delivery of Abigaile Lebron which resulted in birth injuries, severe brain injuries and cerebral palsy, cognitive mental impairment, inability to be fed normally and a gastronomy tube was needed and an inability to develop normal neurological functino (Our medical malpractice team has handled many similar cases).   The Illinois Court held that the limits on non economic damages (damages for pain, suffering and disfigurement) in section 2-1706.5 of the Ill. Code violated the separation of powers clause of the Illinois State Constitution.   To see a copy of the opinion, click here.  Prior to this Court opinion, Illinois victims of medical malpractice were limited to $500,000.00 for pain and suffering damages regardless of the extent of their injuries.  Caps of non-economic damages are especially unfair to widows, orphans, the disabled, the elderly and to women who are less likely to have large economic damages if they are not employed.  The medical malpractice team at Goldberg Finnegan & Mester has represented numerous children and families in the State of Maryland who have suffered from birth injuries.   Christian Mester and Jean Jones (a nurse and attorney) recently resolved a medical malpractice case for $4.15 million dollars on behalf of a child who was deprived of oxygen to the brain during delivery.  This resulted in cerebral palsy.  The parents now have the funds to allow their injured child to obtain the care she needs.
 
In the State of Maryland, we have a very unfair cap on non-economic damages as well.  In Medical Malpractice cases, the cap for claims arising after January 1, 2009 is $665,000.00 for non death cases and $831,250.00 in wrongful death cases if there are multiple claimants.  For personal injury cases that are not medical malpractice cases, the Maryland cap on non-economic damages is $665,000.00 for an individual's claim, $997,500 for wrongful death cases with multiple claimants.  There are cases pending in the Maryland Court of Appeals that challenge Maryland's cap on non-economic damages.   As the President of the Maryland Association for Justice, Kevin Goldberg has worked with the MAJ legislative team to push legislation before the Maryland General Assembly to revise Maryland's unfair Medical Malpractice Cap to bring it back in line with the higher cap for personal injury death cases.
 
To see the Illinois case that invalidated their cap on non-economic damages in Medical Malpractice Cases, click here.

The lawyers at Goldberg, Finnegan & Mester, LLC are  investigating potential lawsuits relating to individuals who received a heart stent at St. Joseph's Medical Center in Towson, Maryland.  Many of the patients who received heart stents at St. Joseph's Hospital may not have actually needed them.  Starting in December, 2009 a number of patients received letters about their cardiac catheterization procedures in which they received heart stents.  The biggest concern is over surgeries performed by Dr. Mark Midei.  The letters sent to patients reportedly indicate that post surgical clinical review procedures revealed that the results of the cath tests were in fact different than indicated on the original heart catheterization report.   Some of these patients may have received unnecessary stents in their heart valves, and thus have been subjected to substantial health risks.  The doctor who is believed to have performed the unnecessary procedures is Dr. Mark Midei.  He was a prominent heart surgeon who has recently stopped practicing medicine and has lost his privileges at St. Joseph's hospital.  What transpired is that some patients were told that they had blockage of 80-95% when in fact they only had a very small amount of blockage--even as low as 10%.  Medical Guidelines reveal that in order for a stent procedure to be necessary, there should be blockage of at least 70%.    Once a stent procedure is performed on a cardiac patient, patients face long term risks including the risk of blood clots in the stent (which can cause a heart attack), and/or other life threatening injuries.  To reduce the risk of clotting in stent patients, many are prescribed a blood thinner such as Plavix (expensive--and has its own risks/side effects).    Our legal team believes that anyone who had an unnecessary cardiac stent procedure performed at St. Josephs has potential legal claims against Dr. Midei, St. Josephs, and possibly others.  Claims would include medical negligence, battery, violation of Maryland's Consumer Protection Act, and possibly even fraud.   Whereas punitive damages are not available in most negligence cases in Maryland, because the cases involving unnecessary stent procedures at St. Josephs involved intentional conduct and was possibly even deceptive and deceiptful, it is quite possible that punitive damages will be available as well.  In December 2005 a Baltimore Jury returned a $5 Million dollar verdict against Dr. Mark G. Midei and Midatlantic Cardivascular Association.  The jury found that the doctor improperly steered a patient to a surgeon employed by the practice rather than to his own surgeon who belonged to a rival group.   After the verdict, it is reported that Dr. Midei said "I've done close to 30,000 procedures on patients and have never been sued until now."  If you or someone you love had a cardiac stent procedure performed at St. Josephs Hospital and/or done by Dr. Midei, call us at 301-589-2999 so that we can evaluate your claim.  

It has been known for years that over 98,000 Americans are needlessly dying every year at the hands of health care providers.  Over 98,000!  And yet, these ghastly figures continue even though they could be prevented.  Dead by Mistake is a website with patient sagas and other information that demonstrates some of the numerous preventable medical errors.  This website was created by journalists from across the country and provides important and moving information for you - they chronicle 2,000,000 - that's Two MILLION - preventable deaths over the past 10 years due to medical errors.  Take charge of your medical care.  Get the information you should know so that medical malpractice / medical negligence hopefully does not happen to you or anyone you love.  The insurance industry and health care industry refuse to accept responsibility and care for people the way you should be treated.  The only way measures will be taken to decrease or prevent these errors is by holding the health care providers and the system accountable in a court of law.  That is what our system of justice allows.  That is what trial lawyers like those at Goldberg, Finnegan & Mester do.  If your mother died from cancer because the radiologist misread her mammogram, calling it normal when it was not, contact a lawyer to hold them accountable.  If your daughter was born with neurological problems and has been diagnosed with cerebral palsy because the obstetrician or midwife ignored the warning signs on the fetal heart rate monitor and did not deliver her at a time to prevent the brain damage, contact a lawyer to hold them accountable.  If you have been injured by medical negligence, let us protect your rights.  For more information about whether you or a loved one has been injured by a preventable medical error, call our Maryland Medical Malpractice Lawyers at: 301-589-2999 x125 (we are located in downtown Silver Spring very close to the Metro Station) or visit our website at www.gfmlawllc.com.
Below, we have attached a release that demonstrates what we have been advocating for years:  that the insurance industry's cries of medical malpractice cases causing a "malpractice crisis" were in fact false and made up by the insurance industry.  Trial lawyers are easy targets and the insurance industry spends tens of millions of dollars every year to distort the truth so that they can continue increasing their profits while decreasing the rates they reimburse health care providers while at the same time raising the rates of insurance and improperly denying valid claims.  It is business practices such as these that demonstrate the importance of continuing equal justice to all under our civil justice system and not a system that only protects those with the most money, like the insurance industry.  Trial lawyers continue to fight for you and your families so that your rights are not further taken away by greedy insurance executives.  The insurance industry's attempts to limit your rights should not be tolerated.  Call your Representatives and Senators and let them know how disgusted you are at being duped by the insurance industry.  Tell your friends and neighbors.  Your family is worth it.

Goldberg, Finnegan & Mester, Protecting Your Rights.

Medical Malpractice Insurers Earning More Than Ever

10 biggest malpractice insurers have average profits higher than 99% of Fortune 500 companies

Washington, DC--As Congress debates nationwide health care reform, a new analysis reveals malpractice insurers have long-played a cruel hoax on legislators and the public.  By systematically distorting profits and losses, insurers created phony "financial crises," so lawmakers would limit the legal rights of injured patients.  Today, while premiums and health care costs skyrocket, malpractice insurers have average profits higher than 99 percent of Fortune 500 companies.

The key findings of the report, which analyzes the annual financial statements of the 10 largest U.S. medical malpractice insurers, include:

  • The average profit of these insurance companies is higher than 99 percent of all Fortune 500 companies and 35 times higher than the Fortune 500 average for the same time period.
  • Malpractice insurers have seen their profit margins range from 5.9 percent to 74.8 percent, with an average of 31.2 percent.
  • Medical malpractice insurers have underestimated profits and overestimated losses, creating overblown insurance "crises" to garner support for limiting patients' legal rights.  Then years later after the "crises" abated, revised filings show the companies were never in the financial peril they claimed.
  • After overestimating losses, insurers have since reported that losses over the last five years have been approximately 13.5 percent lower than initially reported.
  • By overestimating losses, companies have underestimated profits.  Insurers averaged about 5.1 percent higher profits last year and 12.4 percent higher profits two years ago; these levels of profits will likely rise as upward revisions are made.
  • Medical negligence laws were passed under false pretenses.  Overblown reported losses were used by the insurance industry to justify new measures restricting the rights of those injured by medical negligence.

"Insurance companies are gouging doctors on their premiums to mislead lawmakers.  And today, injured patients are often left with no avenue to pursue justice, while health care costs continue to skyrocketing," said American Association for Justice President Anthony Tarricone, managing partner at Kreindler & Kreindler LLP.

"As Congress looks to overhaul our nation's health care system, it's clear that limiting the legal rights of patients won't lower health care costs or cover the uninsured," continued Tarricone.  "The focus should be on eliminating medical errors that injure or kill tens of thousands of Americans every year.  Insurance companies clearly don't need another handout."

As part of its ongoing series on the topic, AAJ earlier released Medical Negligence: A Primer for the Nation's Health Care Debate and The Truth About "Defensive Medicine."  These reports, as well as The Insurance Hoax: How Doctors and Patients Pay for the Huge Earnings of Medical Malpractice Insurers, can be located here.
The following is a statement from Maryland Association for Justice President
Kevin Goldberg:

Columbia, MD--"Last night, President Obama made the case for health care reform to provide coverage for the uninsured and to lower health care costs for all Americans.

"The plan for demonstration projects raised by President Obama will require more detail.  But the focus of any project must be on improving patient safety and reducing medical errors that kill over 98,000 people each year in American hospitals.  Shielding health care providers from accountability will not improve health care.

"The attorneys who represent injured patients see first-hand the effects medical errors have on patients and their families.  Everyone should keep injured people in mind as the debate moves forward.  Providing justice for injured patients should not become barter for compromise on health insurance reform."
The continuing assaults on the civil justice system by the insurance industry and big business have instilled fear in the public: they state that plaintiff's lawsuits are the main reason for higher health care and as such, tort reform is necessary.  Trial lawyers, who protect you and your family when you are injured as a result of someone else's negligence and fight against such lies, have been rebutting this myth for years.  In an article published yesterday in the Baltimore Sun, the author provides further confirmation that health care is not rising because of lawsuits.  The articles states:  "The nonpartisan Congressional Budget Office [CBO], as usual the best source for this kind of analysis, says malpractice costs make up only 2 percent of health care spending. "The evidence available to date does not make a strong case that restricting malpractice liability would have a significant effect," the CBO says."  What it will do, however, is lessen any money available to you or your loved one when you are injured - thus solely benefiting the insurance industry to the detriment of the public.

So, the next time you hear someone comment that lawyers and frivolous lawsuits are driving up the cost of health insurance, tell them they are wrong and provide them with the government research that proves it.  This is also why it is important to make sure you are knowledgeable about your elected public official's stances on tort reform and to hold them accountable for telling the truth and not propagating these lies and myths.  Here is a link to that article:  click here to read.

And if you have been injured as a result of negligent medical care, do not be afraid to call a Maryland Medical Malpractice lawyer to seek justice on your behalf.  We have a registered nurse attorney on staff ready to talk to you and we do not charge a fee unless we recover money for you.  Call us today at (301) 589-2999 extension 125.  Goldberg, Finnegan & Mester - Protecting Your Rights.
For most people, going to the hospital entails a fair amount of stress, pain, and apprehension.  Thus, when the caregivers violate the highest precept of their calling ("first, do no harm") hospital visits result in new, deeper pain.  A Maryland medical malpractice lawyer can help people who have experienced such trauma with filing a medical malpractice case.  Anyone can understand when a doctor or nurse does everything right and can't cure someone.  But when a person holding themselves out to be a medical worker departs from the customs and standards of their profession and causes harm to the innocent patient, compensation through the legal system is available and appropriate.

Licensed medical professionals are required to maintain malpractice insurance in certain states.    There are two reasons for this requirement: (1) sometimes doctors and nurses will make mistakes that have terrible results, for which compensation is necessary, and (2) some doctors and nurses deliberately or negligently fail to live up to the standards of their oath and must be held absolutely responsible to their patients.  Insurance functions as a safety net for doctors and nurses, protecting them from lawsuits and personal liability.

For a successful medical malpractice case, a Maryland medical malpractice attorney must establish the elements of a negligence claim; and a deviation from the standard of care (or a lack of informed consent).  The first of these elements  is that a legal duty existed, which is established any time that a medical caregiver or facility undertakes care of a patient.  Therefore, this element is rarely ever in doubt.  Next, the breach of this duty must be established.  This means that the caregiver failed to adhere to the standard of care for the profession (or so obviously breached the duty that "the thing speaks for itself").  Establishing this breach usually requires expert testimony to explain what the appropriate standard of care is  for the profession (for the specific specialty of the medical doctor).  Usually, if a given course of treatment is acceptable within the field, then it is within the standard of care, whereas if a doctor acts on a hunch or decides that he believes treatment should progress in some novel, never-before-seen way, this could fall outside of the standard of care.  Even in these cases, the treatment could be within the standard if the doctor can establish that he used methods accepted within the profession.

Next, the breach must be shown to be the cause of the injuries sustained.  Therefore, if a patient having a heart attack establishes that the doctor did not properly put a band-aid on the patient's finger that was cut during treatment, that patient can't recover for the heart attack because it was not caused by the negligence, but he might recover for an infection resulting from the band-aid negligence.  In addition to being the cause in this way, a Maryland medical malpractice lawyer must also establish the caregiver's actions caused damages, without which no recovery can occur.
Tuesday's Washington Post contained an article about Michelle Hereford, whose husband died from sepsis (where an infection spreads throughout the body) while being treated at the hospital. Ms. Hereford claims that the hospital ignored the signs and symptoms and was unresponsive to her concerns over how her husband was doing.  By the time the hospital acted, it was too late to save him and Mr. Hereford died.  Ms. Hereford says that she is speaking out because she hopes it will bring about some change, however small. "When mistakes happen in hospitals, it's not because they don't have bells and whistles and technology," she said. "It's because nurses become robots and they don't listen."  Ms. Hereford should be applauded for her courage and her willingness to help others so that this does not happen again.
While it is a tragedy what happened to Ms. Hereford and her husband (and their young children), unfortunately, medical negligence, also known as medical malpractice, is all too common.  And it has nothing to do with doctors and nurses not being decent human beings or making simple mistakes or worrying about rising insurance premiums for doctors:  health care providers must adhere to the standard of care and when they do not (whether they call it a mistake or something else) and their actions or inactions injure someone, they are negligent.  And the rising insurance premiums and doctors fleeing states are myths propagated by the insurance industry to justify its continued greed.
When you or a loved one are injured due to medical negligence, then you need to call an experienced Maryland Medical Malpractice Lawyer to advise you of your rights.  Health care providers need to be held accountable when their negligence causes injury.  Here at Goldberg, Finnegan & Mester, we have experienced medical malpractice lawyers (including a registered nurse-attorney) ready to fight for you.  For more information about medical malpractice/negligence, call us at 301-589-2999 x125 (we are located in downtown Silver Spring very close to the Metro Station) or visit our website at www.gfmlawllc.com.